On Friday, we
arrived at the cottage for the start of summer break. It took me hours to
unpack and settle in, even though I am generally out here once a week. Around 5
pm, I decided to get out for a walk/run with our dog Abby.
Just northeast
of our cottage, there is a sprawling section of rolling prairie—previous host
to a wealthy rancher. It ambles away from the mountains, back toward the city,
hovering above the Bow River. The cliffs
are steep and impossible to climb. The view is compelling. There is an old
run-down cattle fence marking the edge of the property, with a worn path on
either side of the fence, making it appear to be a popular hiking trail.
I was told by
someone here, who was told by someone else, that the property—essentially
abandoned—is owned by one of the residents at Cottage Club. Or was it one of
the developers, I don’t quite remember. It was even intimated that it was okay,
if not perfectly fine, to walk our dogs on that piece of meandering land.
On half a dozen
occasions, I have wandered the land, knowing (at some level) that it was
private property. I am not, by nature, a rule breaker. My first foray onto the
land was with another cottage resident. Not wanting to appear the nervous fool,
I ducked around the fence while the dogs shimmied through the barbed wire. I
have to admit that it is one of the most peaceful walks I have found. Strolling
across carpet juniper entwined with creeping thyme, a brisk breeze brushing
against my back, and the sound of the rollicking river in the background is
healing and grounding. And then, turning back toward home, the canvas is swept
with the alluring Rocky Mountains, just out of range.
On Thursday, I received a phone call
from my daughter in the middle of the day—on the last day of school. She was in
trouble. Damn—so close to making it
through the school year without any more infractions—so close to having my
daughter returned to me…as if (maybe) I would have some magical influence on
her. Damn!
She had been caught breaking the law.
My child and her complicit accomplice were asked by an imposing security man to
take a seat, and explain what they thought they were doing. The police were
called, and each child was encouraged to call their parents.
My feet found
their way over to the barbed entry. I paused as I always do, wondering if it
was really okay. What if I got
caught—or worse? No one knew where I was going. But, as I stood, breathing
heavily after my short run down the gravel road, the pungent perfume of the
silver dogwood invited me in. I shimmied around the barrier and plodded upon
western wheatgrass, soft under my feet.
A
meadow opened up, protected by tall pines and trembling aspen. There is a
rock-hewn fire pit there, with two plastic brown chairs, both over-turned,
likely by the gusting Chinook winds that sail through the area. My dog Abby
darted across hilltops and sand dunes, down paths and prairies, and
occasionally stopped, her nose in the air—scenting something. I watched her for
a sign, not sure if I was more afraid of running into humans or cougars.
As
I sprinted up and over the next bluff, Abby stopped in her tracks as we had
very quickly come upon an older woman sitting alone at a fire. There was no
sign of a dwelling, though I knew that eventually the path led to a ramshackle
cabin. She stared at the fire and I wondered if she was an apparition, but then
her head raised and her eyes took me in. Out of breath, I grabbed the collar of
my dog, and smiled and said, “Hi, how are you?”
Just twenty-nine hours prior to my
transgression, I got a phone call from Superstore.
“Hello,” I answered
“Mom?”
“Hi honey, how are you?” I sang.
“Not very good…. I got caught
stealing,” she sighed.
FWump…My guts tensed; tears sprang to
my eyes and my heart heaved. It had already been an emotional week. I felt deep
sadness. “Oh…that’s…ummm…that’s too bad,” I replied.
I got the details of where she was,
and what was required of me, and after a brief talk with the security
personnel, I hung up. I called my husband Ward right away, looking desperately
for some support. He did not let me down. He volunteered to go and meet with
her, and at first I was reluctant—she would be expecting me, needing me—but
since I was out of the city, and I was having an emotional reaction that was
larger than the event required, I thought it would be best if he went. So,
while he went to deal with this mess, I had a good cry and a long walk, before
meeting up with them at home.
The old woman
sat at the fire, staring at me before answering, “I’m fine,” she finally said.
My armpits itched as she stared at me. She eyed me from beneath her tattered green
baseball cap, long strands of black and grey hair sticking out; she said, “Where are you coming from?”
“Just over at
Cottage Club,” I pointed with my hand in the direction from which I had come
(in case it wasn’t obvious).
She stared at
me; I huffed and puffed; and she said, “You do know that you are on private
property?”
“No,” I hesitantly
answered, and then as I turned to go I looked back and said, “I’m sorry. Have a
good evening.” She said nothing as she watched me go.
Shit, I had broken the law, and been
caught. Surely no one would prosecute. Shit,
she knew where I lived. I wouldn’t be hard to find, with my unique white and
brown striped hair, and my big, fluffy, blonde dog. It was a benign act—wasn’t
it?
The policeman, like the elderly lady,
did “let her off” this time. So, we are in the same boat, aren’t we? Not
really. She cannot set foot on that property—or any property they own—for a
determined period of time. Me, I could take the risk again if I chose to, but I
know that my conscience won’t let me. I got caught, and I don’t like to break
rules. That alone will effectively change my behavior: I will find somewhere
else to walk. Moreover, it is about respect, and I have seen the whites of her
eyes—as she stared me down. What about my daughter? What will motivate her to
change her behavior? Embarrassment? Guilt?—at dragging an innocent friend down
with her. I don’t know.
The thing that I
am wrestling with now is—who committed the worse
crime? Each of us made a decision with risks attached. Until Friday, I was able
to justify my stroll along private property; the only thing that changed on
that day was—I got caught. Prior to
meeting the land owner at the fire, my justifications felt valid: I am not
harming anybody or anything, nobody even knows that I have been here, and
anything that I take in, I am also carrying out. But life has consequences, and
when we make mistakes the consequences eventually catch up with us. I didn’t feel
like I was causing any harm, whereas theft causes harm—that is the difference.
The
reality is: making mistakes is part of the human condition. It is what we do
with the mistake that matters. How do we adequately teach our children to take responsibility
for their mistake, and then to go one step further and attend to the hurt they
have caused in others…and in themselves? I think that we do it through
understanding over misgiving and compassion over judgment. Her actions cannot
exist without consequences; hopefully the consequences will provide a lesson as
well as some thought-provoking reflection—but those are the things we have no
control over. We can only “rule” on the crime, dish out the punishment, and
then, in turn, support her through the tears, the anger, the guilt, and the
difficulty of learning new things as she grows up.
Tell me and I forget.
Teach
me and I remember.
Involve
me and I will learn.
Benjamin
Franklin